An Airbus A380 takes part in a flying display June 19 three days before the opening of the 48th Paris Air Show at the Le Bourget airport near Paris. Rep. Norm Dicks, D-Wash., says the WTO ruling confirms a complaint by the U.S. in 2004 that shows "all Airbus aircraft have received illegal subsidies and that these have caused material harm to Boeing." The World Trade Organization has ruled that the European Union provided illegal subsidies to Airbus for its aircraft, a House Democrat said Friday.